Read only the bold text. Would your donors know exactly what you’re asking them to do?
Before your next year-end appeal goes out, run this test.
Read only the bold text. Would your donors know exactly what you’re asking them to do?
It’s the first thing we check when leaders send us their appeal drafts. Most donors don’t read an appeal from top to bottom. They scan it: a glance at the opening, a skim down the page, a look at the P.S. In those few seconds, they decide whether to give. Bold text is what tells the scanning eye where to stop.
Try it on these two letters.
Letter 1
Dear [Name],
[Student] walked into her first rehearsal unsure she belonged. By spring, she was taking a bow with the rest of the ensemble.
Her confidence grew. Her family says she’s a different kid at home. And she’s not alone.
This year, [X] young people rehearsed, performed, and created alongside working artists. But there are more waiting for their chance. Right now, [X] students are on our waitlist.
Your $250 gift last year helped make moments like this possible. Will you consider increasing to $500 this year so more students can take the stage?
Together, we can make sure the next student who walks in unsure leaves knowing she belongs.
With appreciation,
[Executive Director]
P.S. Thanks to a $100,000 matching gift from [Donor], your gift of $500 will be matched through December 31. Double your impact before the year ends.
Letter 2
Dear [Name],
[Student] walked into her first rehearsal unsure she belonged. By spring, she was taking a bow with the rest of the ensemble.
Her confidence grew. Her family says she’s a different kid at home. And she’s not alone.
This year, [X] young people rehearsed, performed, and created alongside working artists. But there are more waiting for their chance. Right now, [X] students are on our waitlist.
Your $250 gift last year helped make moments like this possible. Will you consider increasing to $500 this year so more students can take the stage?
Together, we can make sure the next student who walks in unsure leaves knowing she belongs.
With appreciation,
[Executive Director]
P.S. Thanks to a $100,000 matching gift from [Donor], your gift of $500 will be matched through December 31. Double your impact before the year ends.
Same story, same ask, same match. Give Letter 1 a five-second scan and you come away with nothing. Do the same with Letter 2 and you know exactly what’s being asked, how much, by when, and why now.
Three habits that make the difference
Bold the ask. Not the story, not the stat. The ask. The story is what earns the gift, but the ask is what a scanning donor needs to find.
Bold the P.S., and put the deadline in it. The P.S. is often the first thing a donor reads, and a deadline gives them a reason to act now instead of “later.”
Don’t bold everything. If everything is bold, nothing is. Two bolded moments, the ask and the P.S., are usually all a letter needs.
The same rule applies to email. Inboxes are even more of a scanning environment than mailboxes, so the bold ask and the deadline matter just as much.
The power of bold
Respect it. Use it. Make it easy for people to give, clear how much you’re asking for, and obvious when the deadline is.
Deadlines don’t pressure donors. They help them decide.
Happy year-end fundraising, friends!
Working on your appeal right now? Reply to this email and tell me what you’re wrestling with. I’m glad to take a look.